Advice for C.C. Finlay

Congratulations to C.C. Finlay (CCF), who has just been named the editor of The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction (FSF), taking over from Gordon Van Gelder (GVG) who will remain as publisher. Genius choice by GVG (I always said GVG has an eye for talent).

As CCF surveys his vast new empire, he faces a critical challenge, one that will define his literary legacy and help shape the future of our field. He must pick his rejection catchphase.

GVG’s catchphrase was “alas” as in “My assistant liked it but this story didn’t grab me, alas.” Let us pause to consider the dense layers of meaning that GVG packed into this 11-word sentence. There are characters in conflict: the good cop (assistant) vs. bad cop (GVG). There’s a twist: at first, everything looks good until suddenly the grabbing mechanism malfunctions and the hero goes into a death spiral. And after the tragedy, the single Shakespearean coda: alas.

Indeed, GVG’s rejections produced an entirely new word into the English language: the alas-o-gram. As in “Here comes the mailman with another alas-o-gram.” Alas, the term “alas-o-gram” (like the Hoboken post office) now faces a bleak future.

So with that in mind, here are my suggestions for CCF’s catchphrase.

  • No soup for you!
  • Close, but no cigar
  • What were you thinking?
  • tl;dr
  • My eyes! They burn!
  • I can’t unread that
  • After reading your story, I thought “That’s ten minutes I’m not getting back”
  • I’m accepting your story–NOT!
  • Welcome to Reject City. Population: you
  • F&SF needs this story like a fish needs a bicycle
  • To the last, I grapple with thee; From Hell’s heart, I stab at thee; For hate’s sake, I spit my last breath at thee.
  • This isn’t the publication venue you’re looking for. Move along.
  • Keep your day job
  • Your storification made me scratch my gulliver. I semifathom your newspeak horrowshow, but can’t glimmer your tellings. Doubleplus ungood.

As an added bonus, here’s a little something for aspiring writers. After sending a submission to CCF, try this prayer:

Now I Finlay me down to sleep

I pray CC my sub to keep

If he rejects before I wake

I do believe my heart will break

5 thoughts on “Advice for C.C. Finlay

  1. bethlcato

    My suggestion is for the submissions that he holds for extra consideration, wherein he becomes the Dread Pirate Finlay.

    “Good night, author. Good work. Sleep well. I’ll most likely reject you in the morning.”

  2. Ruth Nestvold

    Reblogged this on Ruth Nestvold – Indie Adventures and commented:
    I got a kick out of this. I received many alas-o-grams in my day, but I always kept trying, since Gordon was so wonderful about rejecting promptly, which meant I could turn my stories around way faster than with any other market. I had the great good fortune of selling one story to GVG, “Mars: A Traveler’s Guide,” which ended up being nominated for a Nebula. 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s